The Showdown: Cooperatives Vs. Stock Exchange-driven Exploitation

When you have got a global market, people do not think they can actually impact on the economic situation in which they find themselves. But they can impact on their local environment. There is this huge renaissance of community going on.

  • Pauline Green, President of the International Co-operative Alliance (ICA)

By Trond Overland
(March 2012) – Ours is a time of increasing collective concern and rapidly decreasing faith in the self-centred capitalist system. Not that the capitalist care. While the global market crisis continues on its hazardous journey towards brutal meltdown, cooperative models emerge as new, dignified ways of doing business.

The incoming system: Cooperatives
The Outgoing system: Stock exchange-driven exploitation
The PROUT position

The Incoming System: Cooperatives

Globally, the cooperative structure is diverse and dispersed, has tens of thousands of member businesses, and employs 100 million people, which is 20 per cent more than the jobs generated by multinational companies. Across the world, cooperatives have 1 billion members, about three times the number of individual shareholders out there, reports The Age*. The 300 biggest cooperatives collectively generate revenue of $US1.6 trillion a year, equivalent to the world’s ninth largest economy, Spain.

It’s the members who own the business. It’s they who take the strategic direction of the co-operative through their election to the boards. It’s a democratic process. And that is what distinguishes us.

– Pauline Green of the Geneva-based ICA said to The Age.

“During the last four years in the financial crisis across the world, co-operative and mutual sector has come through largely unscathed. We have come through with an increased asset-base. We have increased deposits, whereas our high-street competitors have in many countries collapsed,” Green stated. “In the UK, the co-operative bank over the last two years has seen a 79 per cent increase in account switches from our corporate competitors.”

The United Nations has made 2012 the International Year of the Co-operative. It is the first time the UN has given this honor to a business model. UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said:

Cooperatives are a reminder to the international community that it is possible to pursue both economic viability and social responsibility.

The Outgoing System: Stock Exchange–driven Exploitation

Asked earlier this month what he thinks about the fact that the US unemployment rate is falling right now and companies in the Standard & Poor’s 500 are making more money than ever, David Stockman, the budget director of the Reagan administration, said*: “That’s very short-term. Look at the data that really counts. The 131.7 million jobs in November was first achieved in February 2000. That number has gone nowhere for 12 years. Another measure is the rate of investment in new plant and equipment. There is no sustained net investment in our economy. The rate of growth since 2000 in money put into office buildings, factories, software and other equipment has been 0.8% — hardly measurable. We’re stalled, stuck. Where it is now is totally artificial. It’s the result of massive purchases by not only the Fed but all of the other central banks of the world.

“What’s wrong with that is that it doesn’t come out of savings. It’s made-up money. It’s printing press money. When the Fed buys $5 billion worth of bonds this morning, which it’s doing periodically, it simply deposits $5 billion in the bank accounts of the eight dealers they buy the bonds from. The consequences are horrendous. If you could make the world rich by having all the central banks print unlimited money, then we have been making a mistake for the last several thousand years of human history. At some point confidence is lost, and people don’t want to own the (Treasury) paper. I mean why in the world, when the inflation rate has been 2.5% for the last 15 years, would you want to own a five-year note today at 80 basis points (0.8%)?

“If the central banks ever stop buying, or actually begin to reduce their totally bloated, abnormal, freakishly large balance sheets, all of these speculators are going to sell their bonds in a heartbeat. That’s what happened in Greece. Here’s the heart of the matter. The Fed is a patsy. It is a pathetic dependent of the big Wall Street banks, traders and hedge funds. Everything (it does) is designed to keep this rickety structure from unwinding. If you had a (former Fed Chairman) Paul Volcker running the Fed today — utterly fearless and independent and willing to scare the hell out of the market any day of the week — you wouldn’t have half, you wouldn’t have 95%, of the speculative positions today,” Stockman concludes

The PROUT Position

The concentration of great wealth beyond the influence of ordinary citizens is at the heart of the mounting difficulties that now make global capitalism look like the Nexus of Evil, the Mother of All Conspiracy Theories, etc. As a first step towards establishing a real economy of real people, stock exchanges and their exploitative trading tools should go into permanent lockdown.

In a seminal discourse in 1984, PROUT founder P.R. Sarkar exhorted:

Capitalists, in either their singular or collective forms, are the most pernicious economic exploiters today. All over the world they are continually exploiting local economies and draining their wealth. In nearly all cases the profits they accrue are spent outside the local area and remitted to outside stockholders and parent companies. An essential measure to control this economic exploitation is that the speculative markets in all countries of the world should be closed down immediately.*

Closing down the leading institutions of an exploitative system is a first step. However, the subsequent constructive steps may seem even more important.

The world and its people need a decentralized consumption-oriented economy where profits are for developing the economy of everybody and not only of a few. It will be the job of lawmakers and the people to evolve further such a humanist system out of the present co-operative structure.

Money needs to be kept rolling, otherwise it loses its practical value. Right now, capitalists are holding back as they are not sure where they can get optimum returns. By their present unwillingness to invest they hurt the entire world and threaten to offset an unprecedented depression. But their greed does not allow them to act otherwise. They keep the whole world hostage to their defective mentality. Consequently, the days of capitalism as the dominating world system are numbered.

The future lies in cooperatives!

The PROUT cooperative system
PROUT compared with capitalism and communism

* Sources:
The Age (Australia)
USA Today
“Socio-economic Movements”, PROUT in a Nutshell Part 13, Ananda Marga Publications

Copyright PROUT Globe 2011

2 thoughts on “The Showdown: Cooperatives Vs. Stock Exchange-driven Exploitation”

  1. My concern is how will PROUT deal with the mega rich in the short term, both individuals and mining and business corporations, who are holding governments the world over to ransom and in many cases preventing more urgent and progressive policies from becoming a reality, and thus seriously disadvantaging billions of people. Needed reforms , are put on permanent hold at present or are watered down, and a negative mindset is generated. Mental depression and a sense of hopelessness results in a lack of action on the ground. This psychic exploitation is very evident. At present it may work for those greed infected people who are hoarding their wealth, but it is a an unnatural situation that cannot continue.
    Can Prout actually come up with a plan to deal with this and cause the least possible harm when the final collapse comes?
    In Australia, not many people would be aware that a single woman, Gina Rinehart, daughter of western Australian mining magnate Lang Hancock, has more wealth than governments, Qantas,and some of the large retail corporations put together, and her wealth is growing at an alarming rate and all the while she is keen to exercise more of her power and influence in the public sphere with her extraordinarily retrogrssive ideas, so as to safeguard and continue to grow her wealth without restriction. Such a situation is so unbalanced it will of course eventually fall down
    but it is occurring in many other places, so can this be addressed now, or is it just a waiting game?

  2. Agreed, something needs to be said and done about such absurd wealth distribution. How about standing up for “wealth cap” and pushing economic democracy, decentralized economy … as long as you haven’t got the legal on your side you are not really in position to effect concrete changes other than by campaigning in various ways. Stunts and sustained movements in that direction could a lot of good to “negative mindsets, mental depressions, hopelessness” ;>) and help build a rational alternative.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *